OK to row every day?

Rowing for weight loss or weight control? Start here.

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby Cayenne » March 26th, 2016, 6:07 pm

Sekitori,

You make excellent points and I can't say any of them are wrong.

I have always thought that "The Beatles" was a terrible name for a musical group. :D

Hope you enjoy the book and, if you do, spread the word. So many people stand to benefit !

(BTW, if you like it, why not share your suggestions with Mr. Ordway? Perhaps a future edition could be re-titled in the hope of reaching a broader audience. Of course, the message, not the title, is what really matters. I mean, even if the Beatles had stayed with "The Quarrymen" or "Johnny and Moondogs" as their group name, their music would have been just as great. FWIW, even though I personally like the title, "Row daily, etc..." if the book was re-named, "Move your a$$ back and forth...alot !" well, who knows...?)
Cayenne
1k Poster
 
Posts: 108
Joined: May 5th, 2006, 10:28 am

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby jla956 » May 3rd, 2016, 9:25 am

Dittos to the RowPro recommendation, plus there are plenty of other 2nd party recommendations on the C2 website - http://www.concept2.com/service/softwar ... are#rowpro

I've been rowing on a C2 for almost 30 years and there are times that you just get "burnt out" but the programs like RowPro are a game-changer - they will keep you engaged and are fun too. I had decades of just rowing to stay in shape. I would set goals to challenge me but with RowPro you can workout smart with very customized programs. I find that I can work out for shorter periods of time and get far better results that are measurable. You're using the C2 WOD which is good and breaks the monotony, but RowPro has built in exercise programs specific to what you need. Take a look at it or some of the other programs that are available.

Regarding your original question as to how often you should row - let your body tell you that. I have a Polar HRM and I also use that with the SweetBeat program (www.sweetwaterhrv.com) which measures your (HRV) Heart Rate Variability. I get instant feedback every morning when I take a 2 minute test to see what my HRV is and the program will tell you whether it's OK to workout or if you should skip a day. I use it during my rowing to measure results and also for a two minute period afterwards to measure recovery.

All I can say is that this program is "spot on" when it comes to giving you exact feedback. Just Google Heart Rate Variability or visit the SweetBeat website for a good explanation of what HRV is and how it impacts you. Good luck and enjoy your Erg!
Concept 2 Model B
"rowing since '88"
jla956
Paddler
 
Posts: 2
Joined: April 18th, 2016, 2:49 pm
Location: Dallas

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby grahamcawood » January 8th, 2018, 8:43 pm

Yes! Very OK to row daily. Just another daily function - like breakfast.
I do a 30 minute erg daily, at 25spm, 1:1 work:recovery ratio, 2 breaths per stroke. Try for the same perceived effort . About 3 years ago I started getting monthly split jumps from 2.03 to about 2.20. This gradually dropped over the next month, and then jumped again.I drew a graph of these splits and showed it to my doctor. This led quickly to 5x bypass surgery. After 3 weeks I was back on the erg for 30 minutes daily, starting at 3.05, and not pulling beyond the knees to safeguard the sternum. Back to 2,05 now. I'm 70.
Thank you Doctors, and thank you erg for highlighting my problem!!!
Have fun!
grahamcawood
Paddler
 
Posts: 22
Joined: November 27th, 2014, 12:17 am

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby Ombrax » January 10th, 2018, 3:39 am

I think it all depends on whether your mind and your body can take it.

In my case my right shoulder needs a day to rest from "normal" workouts (I have a problem with the labrum) and two days rest after very hard workouts. If I took it easy I probably could row everyday, but part of the idea of exercising is to push yourself and improve, so I have a hard time just doing "easy rows." Lately I've been rowing either every other day or 3x a week, depending on how things fall out in a given week.

Good Luck
User avatar
Ombrax
1k Poster
 
Posts: 176
Joined: April 20th, 2013, 2:05 am
Location: St Louis, MO

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby Dangerscouse » January 10th, 2018, 8:50 am

I agree with Ombrax, it's a very subjective decision. You will know fairly quickly what is sustainable for you as your mind and body will soon tell you to rest if you need to.

Personally I need 2 days rest but I also do a 45min spin class and dynamic hot pilates every week so i need to have some sort of rest as I get up at 4:30am for my rowing / weights.
44 Years Old; 6' 4"; 92kg; Liverpool, England 2k= 6:45; 5k= 17:46; 10k= 36:21 60mins= 16,317m HM= 1:18:40; FM= 2:49:39; 50k= 3:28:18; 75k=5:29:15; 100k= 7:52:44; 12hrs = 153km

Instagram: stuwenman
Dangerscouse
2k Poster
 
Posts: 478
Joined: April 27th, 2014, 11:11 am
Location: Liverpool, England

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby Steve1960VA » January 10th, 2018, 5:13 pm

grahamcawood wrote:Yes! Very OK to row daily. Just another daily function - like breakfast.
I do a 30 minute erg daily, at 25spm, 1:1 work:recovery ratio, 2 breaths per stroke. Try for the same perceived effort . About 3 years ago I started getting monthly split jumps from 2.03 to about 2.20. This gradually dropped over the next month, and then jumped again.I drew a graph of these splits and showed it to my doctor. This led quickly to 5x bypass surgery. After 3 weeks I was back on the erg for 30 minutes daily, starting at 3.05, and not pulling beyond the knees to safeguard the sternum. Back to 2,05 now. I'm 70.
Thank you Doctors, and thank you erg for highlighting my problem!!!
Have fun!


A very interesting and inspiring story. Thanks for resurrecting this thread and for posting. After reading through this thread I'd planned on quoting some other posts, but then I noticed how old this thread is, and decided against. Some of those folks might not visit here anymore...

There are, though, a number of interesting points raised in this thread, and there's one particularly well-written post that makes lots of good points. General sedentary behavior by the populace of most first-world countries, the "Row daily, breathe deeply..." book, etc.

As for myself, now that the US NCAA football championship game is behind us, I'm trying to get started erging faithfully, again. Made a modest effort early this AM. I really think it's important for me to do it daily, or very nearly daily (miss a single day here and there). Though I was never very capable, I think I was most capable when I was working hard nearly every day.
Male. Virginia, USA. Born 1960. 6'4" (1.93 m). 268 pounds (122 kg). C2 Model D, PM 5.

Am erging for fitness. Weight loss OK if it comes.
Steve1960VA
1k Poster
 
Posts: 190
Joined: March 5th, 2017, 11:31 am

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby sekitori » January 10th, 2018, 10:06 pm

To me, rowing every day became not just a source of exercise but an obsession. At one time, I rowed every day for well over three years for between a half hour and an hour a session. No matter how I felt, I continued and didn't miss a day. For some strange reason, this streak became unusually important to me. I was so obsessed with it continuing that I didn't want it to ever stop. It got to a point that even if a workout wasn't that good, it was still okay because I completed it. I began confusing quantity with quality. Then it occurred to me that I really should take an occasional day off to get some much needed rest. It became a matter of extending the streak even longer or doing something that I thought would benefit my health. One day, I chose not to row and that day was hell because I knew the streak was finally over. The next day, I had a very good workout because that day off helped me more than I could ever imagine. Since then, I row for six days a week and take one day completely off from any exercise at all. Taking a day off was an excellent decision and I never regretted making it. As far as I'm concerned, it's perfectly okay to take a break from exercise once a week. But when I do work out, I try to make it count.

A couple of years ago, a book called "Row Daily, Breathe Deeply, Live Better" was mentioned in this discussion group. The main idea was that in order to gain the most out of rowing, you had to do it every single day and that taking a day off could somehow prove to be at least somewhat harmful. I finally read the book and while its aim is admirable, the advice given often seems ridiculous. I learned that this book was published by iUniverse which is a vanity press where the author pays to have his or her book published. I can see why no regular publisher would want anything to do with it.

Here are a few quotes to show what I mean:
“The book is not intended to motivate you”. It was the most motivational book I ever read. That motivation was totally misplaced but it was still present throughout the book.
“Find or buy a rowing machine today and start rowing now”. An overly simplistic statement. It assumes you can get on a rower having absolutely no experience or prior instruction and start using it successfully right away. No mention of learning how to use it first.
“Planning to exercise six days a week will lead to five or four or three". Not if you're disciplined enough to keep at six days per week. And if you're not, working out for three or four days a week is a lot better than not working out at all.
“You should not expect to come back after a day off performing at the same level you achieved before”. That's true. After a day off, your performance should be even better. :-)
“Your starting point should be that taking a day off is the primary error to avoid”. That's the best "error" I ever made.
"The essential point is to row every day. There is no required level of skill or effort”. Wrong. As I stated previously, you have to learn how to use an erg properly first. If you don't, you'll either get injured or get so frustrated that you'll give up. And even if you do know how to use it, if you don't exert much effort, you will acccomplish very little.
“See how a high number of consecutive days you can reach each month and compare that over time”. That makes no sense at all.

Here is the author's view about buying a used rower:
"If you wish to buy a used, older machine, you can fix it yourself”. Not unless you're a Carl Watts clone. It's the same as saying anyone who buys a used car should be a mechanic.

Finally, here are some of his definitions. These are the author's exact words:
“Rower--Someone who rows”. I believe we learned descriptions like that in the first grade.
“Handle--The portion of an oar or rowing machine where the rower places his or her hands”. No comment.
“Seat”—The small padded platform on wheels on which you sit”. I agree that on a rower, you sit on the seat. What I do not agree with is the "padded" part. Some seats are not well padded or even padded at all. Unfortunately, they include seats on the C2.

I've wanted to state my opinions about this book for a long time and I finally have the chance to do so. If you want a highly motivational book about rowing that doesn't make much sense, this is the one to get. Sixteen bucks from Amazon where it got a surprising rating of 4.1 stars. Maybe I'm missing something. Or maybe the reviewers were friends and relatives of the author.
sekitori
1k Poster
 
Posts: 175
Joined: November 29th, 2007, 5:13 pm

Re: OK to row every day?

Postby Ripples » January 19th, 2018, 12:01 am

sekitori wrote:
A couple of years ago, a book called "Row Daily, Breathe Deeply, Live Better" was mentioned in this discussion group. The main idea was that in order to gain the most out of rowing, you had to do it every single day and that taking a day off could somehow prove to be at least somewhat harmful. I finally read the book and while its aim is admirable, the advice given often seems ridiculous. I learned that this book was published by iUniverse which is a vanity press where the author pays to have his or her book published. I can see why no regular publisher would want anything to do with it.

Here are a few quotes to show what I mean:
“The book is not intended to motivate you”. It was the most motivational book I ever read. That motivation was totally misplaced but it was still present throughout the book.
“Find or buy a rowing machine today and start rowing now”. An overly simplistic statement. It assumes you can get on a rower having absolutely no experience or prior instruction and start using it successfully right away. No mention of learning how to use it first.
“Planning to exercise six days a week will lead to five or four or three". Not if you're disciplined enough to keep at six days per week. And if you're not, working out for three or four days a week is a lot better than not working out at all.
“You should not expect to come back after a day off performing at the same level you achieved before”. That's true. After a day off, your performance should be even better. :-)
“Your starting point should be that taking a day off is the primary error to avoid”. That's the best "error" I ever made.
"The essential point is to row every day. There is no required level of skill or effort”. Wrong. As I stated previously, you have to learn how to use an erg properly first. If you don't, you'll either get injured or get so frustrated that you'll give up. And even if you do know how to use it, if you don't exert much effort, you will acccomplish very little.
“See how a high number of consecutive days you can reach each month and compare that over time”. That makes no sense at all.

Here is the author's view about buying a used rower:
"If you wish to buy a used, older machine, you can fix it yourself”. Not unless you're a Carl Watts clone. It's the same as saying anyone who buys a used car should be a mechanic.

Finally, here are some of his definitions. These are the author's exact words:
“Rower--Someone who rows”. I believe we learned descriptions like that in the first grade.
“Handle--The portion of an oar or rowing machine where the rower places his or her hands”. No comment.
“Seat”—The small padded platform on wheels on which you sit”. I agree that on a rower, you sit on the seat. What I do not agree with is the "padded" part. Some seats are not well padded or even padded at all. Unfortunately, they include seats on the C2.

I've wanted to state my opinions about this book for a long time and I finally have the chance to do so. If you want a highly motivational book about rowing that doesn't make much sense, this is the one to get. Sixteen bucks from Amazon where it got a surprising rating of 4.1 stars. Maybe I'm missing something. Or maybe the reviewers were friends and relatives of the author.



Thanks for that review. Was about to buy the book ($6 for the Kindle version), then read the quotes you noted. I'll pass and continue being motivated by goals I've set for this summer on the water.
Ripples
500m Poster
 
Posts: 51
Joined: February 10th, 2017, 10:37 pm
Location: Forty miles south of the Straits of Mackinac

Previous

Return to Weight Loss & Weight Control

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests