rascott wrote:Glad you're back Robert! Robert, have you thought about doing the 5K PP? Your strength is still very strong (likely much stronger than I am) but your cardio is lacking currently. The full PP is good for cardio but I feel meters or perhaps a plan like the 5K PP would build your cardio back quicker. Just a thought.
Mike - interesting. What is it about the 5K plan that you think would be beneficial? I've had a quick look and at first glance it looks harder than the standard PP. Is that it? More intensity for longer?
thanks
Just the fact that you've done a round or so of the Pete Plan already (and that you're an experienced rower, albeit years ago) to me means that you'd likely be bored by the Beginner PP. I think that would be too basic for you to enjoy. The 5K PP (to me) is just basically like the last few weeks of the BPP with added sessions. It is hard but I think if the intensity/speed of the interval sessions are began at a reasonable level, it would help build cardio quite a bit. Based off some of your times current, I'm guessing your cardio needs built up. You seem to have some power but the full PP mostly enhances where you are right now. If your base fitness is off, that's all it will show. That's essentially what happened to me last round, I saw that my base fitness was off (from where I was when I raced this year). Right now, I think you might benefit from more base building first. It's also a 12 week program and most that I've read on base building recommend at least 12 weeks to accomplish that.
As far as your "intensity" question, it's just a different intensity. It's more AT work/distance tolerance rather than speed work. The full PP is geared more for full power. With the shorter rests on the 5K PP, it will limit your ability to do as fast of work so it's just different intensity, not necessarily that much easier or harder. I know some rowers that do 10Ks all the time I would find incredibly painful (just my preference) that avoid 2K/1K and 500m work. They find that stuff intolerable (those guys would likely benefit from doing the full PP more often!).
The full PP will also accomplish much of the same things assuming you're rowing mininum 8K on all of your SS days. Skipping the SS sessions won't improve your cardio just from the HIIT sessions. In my opinion, the SS sessions are just as important as the intervals (if not more important for recovery and aerobic base building).
If the full PP is done as written, the full PP and the 5K PP are around (roughly) the same meters.
Full PP - 4K (fast intervals plus 1K Warm up = 5K)/8K minimum/7.5K (intermediate intervals)/8K/5K minimum TT/8K = 42K meters (with 8Ks for SS days)
5K PP - 10K/6K (fast intervals)/10K/6K (intermediate intervals)/10K/6K (3 X 2K) = 49K including 1K WU for the fast intervals
So if you row 10K on the full PP on SS days, it's around the same meters through the week. Main difference is that you're working aerobic ability not speed. If you talk to most experienced rowers (more than I), they will tell you there are 3/4 things that matter in rowing. The most important being your base aerobic fitness. Then strength, AT/Lactic Acid Clearance and tolerance and then Speed last. Speed can be built the quickest of all these components.
Sorry for the long answer. Would love to hear from a more experienced person. Henry, Stu, Tom, Rod (or many others)?